Welcome to Donnelly's Public House
Donnelly's Public House, located at 1 Water St in Fairport, NY, is a celebrated neighborhood pub that masterfully combines warm hospitality with delicious food. Guests rave about the extensive beer selection and expertly crafted cocktails. The vibrant atmosphere invites families, couples, and friends alike, while the outdoor seating enhances the experience. Signature dishes include mouthwatering buffalo chicken salad, perfectly seared burgers, and indulgent loaded tots with cheese sauce. Patrons, including seasoned chefs and passionate foodies, resonate with the quality and consistency of every meal. Owners Aimee and her husband create a welcoming space that leaves a lasting impression, making Donnelly's a must-visit destination.
-
1 Water St, Fairport, NY 14450, United States Hotline: +1 585-377-5450
Welcome to Donnelly's Public House, a hidden gem located at 1 Water St, Fairport, NY 14450. This charming establishment has quickly become known as a beloved neighborhood pub, offering a warm and inviting atmosphere that feels like home the moment you step inside. With its rich selection of craft beers and an extensive menu that showcases delightful pub fare, it is easy to see why guests return time and again.
One of the standout features of Donnelly's is its exceptional service, consistently praised by patrons. Aimee, the owner and your personal guide to the menu, has garnered admiration for her genuine hospitality and excellent recommendations. As Chef Dan from Lancaster noted, "She made our visit so special." Whether it’s the Buffalo chicken salad, which is described as “spectacular”, or the mornay cheese sauce that pairs perfectly with their famed tater tots, the attention to flavor and quality is evident in every dish.
For those eager for a true taste of pub culture, Donnelly's excels with its large, perfectly seared burgers and impressive wings, often compared to turkey legs for their size and flavor. Locals rave about the build-your-own burger option, which can be customized to suit your palate, or the tantalizing Taco salad that caught J.G.’s attention post-race. You won’t want to miss the Friday fish fry, a local favorite that, according to Julie Millar, is so good that it often sells out early.
The ambiance at Donnelly's is another highlight. With outdoor seating available, dining here becomes a delightful experience, especially during the summer. Families, couples, and groups alike find a place at Donnelly's, where the vibe is friendly and welcoming. As Jennifer points out, the bar staff's expertise not only extends to the breadth of craft beers but also includes clever cocktail mixing, ensuring there’s something for everyone.
A visit to Donnelly's Public House is more than just a meal; it's an experience steeped in community spirit, fantastic service, and remarkable flavors. Whether you're a local or just passing through, this pub provides a comforting retreat that will undoubtedly leave a lasting memory in your heart. So, next time you find yourself in Fairport, make sure to stop by and enjoy the delightful offerings at Donnelly's—the place where friends are made and memories are cherished.
Aimee, Was such a Treat for two travelers from Lancaster, We Loved everything about this place, I’m a chef and not one thing was out of place Here, everything was so delicious, if you’re like us and on the Erie Canal Adventures boats and have one place to stop, choose Here! You have to ask for Aimee the server / Owner, she will make your visit so special, She did ours with the very best recommendations, The Buffalo chicken salad was spectacular, The Cheese sauce (mornay) was unbelievable, the tots were the best bargain for what seemed like the hundreds you got! Ask for them with the cheese sauce you can’t go wrong! The wings looked like Turkey legs, the Burgers appeared perfectly seared, large sizes all around, This will be one of those places that we won’t soon forget and will measure every other pub style Faire by, They set the bar unbelievably high, Such a Gorgeous memory of this place will always remain in my Heart because of the kind Service, phenomenal food, and awesome atmosphere out on the patio, Loved it! Loved it! Loved it! Thank you again Aimee, for making our Visit Something we won’t soon forget, You’re exactly the best kind of steward the restaurant business needs and so seldom finds, not to mention community Ambassador right in Your centrally located spot for a community like Fairport, Who won’t be forgotten, because of the special people like you and your husband who’ve dedicated their lives and time to a place & public like this who I hope keeps you successfully in business for a very, very long time, because Not only are You doing something special every single day for the people who remain Here, but also for the people like myself who because of you and your Restaurant, can’t wait to come back! I’ll be remembering Donnelly’s Fondly in my Heart for a very long time, until I can see ya’ll again which will never be soon enough! -Chef Dan From Lancaster County, PA
We were in Rochester on a trip from Kentucky and went here for dinner on a Saturday night. Our server was Danielle who was very sweet and made sure we had gotten what we needed. My family all said their food was good.
Great service, food and beers! The tap list is always solid. Actually, it’s the best in Rochester! The food is fantastic and the service is top notch. I am glad this spot is so close to home for me!
Popular, warm, neighborhood pub. Staff is so welcoming and friendly, everyone feels like an old friend here. It’s nice for families, couples, and groups. Extensive beers on tap and full bar with skilled bartenders. Good pub food with rotating specials. While I generally have simple tastes in adult beverages, the bar staff has demonstrated skill mixing more complicated cocktails, and depth of knowledge regarding the multitude of whiskeys and craft beers on offer.
The appetizers were great! I really Loved the pretzel and it tastes great with a side of cheese if you don’t like the mustard. I also had mushrooms sandwich with fries and it was perfectly cooked and crispy fries. Definitely will be back. The server was so polite and on the ball with everything. Great Food and beer spot.
Ireland has a home in Fairport and it's at Donnelly's Public house. From the moment you arrive it feels like home. Great sandwichs and Chili. You must check it out.
What do you look for in a restaurant? Consistency. Donnelly's nails it every time. My go-to is Build Your Own Burger (don't forget the meat sauce). Chicken wings? Heck yes. With football season here, every sunday that has an afternoon game, they got 10 for 10 special - dine in only. They kill it with the salads too. Had a 10k race - i'm typically a creature of habit. But i decided to go crazy, and order a salad instead of my burger. The Taco salad - probably in my top 3. The service - amazing. Outside seating always available.
Love this place. Rich, Lindsey, Annie and the rest of the staff all make you feel welcome and at home. The food comes out quick and hot. They have different specials each week, which never disappoint, and their Friday fish fry is delicious. Just don’t wait too long to go, because it does sell out sometimes. The outside space is nice in the summertime! I highly recommend Donnelly’s and love supporting local businesses.